The Miracle of Regathering

The Jewish prophet Ezekiel wrote of the future return of his people to their ancestral homeland 2500 years ago. It is a true miracle that the Jewish people who have suffered exile, persecution, forced assimilation and near annihilation have not only survived, but regathered into their eternal homeland. This blog is intended to stir hearts and minds to contemplate the importance of this modern miracle and to generate dialogue about current cultural, geopolitical and spiritual issues that impact us ALL.

Monday, April 8, 2013

Holocaust Remembrance Day - A Day of Grief, A Day of Hope

Sixty-seven years ago, my father and mother along with my uncle Zvi and aunt Vita moved from Trieste, Italy to Bat Galim.  Bat Galim was a small beach area in the heart of the port city of Haifa in the then British colony of Palestine.  The four of them took up residence in a one bedroom apartment because it was all they could afford, and that barely.  The two best of friends, having fought side-by-side in the Palestinian unit of the British Army against the Germans for 6 years, were still part of the British service but had to work at night driving taxis to make a little extra money for their fledgling families to survive.

It was a difficult life in the post-war middle-east territory.  The dream of all Jews after the Holocaust and World War II - to have a place to call home where Jews could live in peace for the first time in nearly 2000 years - was a struggle.  As a British colony, the spoils of victory over the Ottomans in World War I, the region was controlled by British "occupiers" whose soldiers and service workers didn't want to be there and were dealing with constant conflict, both politically and physically.

Despite a commitment by the British government through Lord Balfour in 1917 of developing the territory as a homeland for the Jewish people and the mandate of the League of Nations to divide the land into Jewish and Arab regions, politicking had usurped promises and World War II had taken attention away from this mandate.  But, in the shadow of the Holocaust, Jews who were now desperately trying to move to the region despite strict quotas by the British, were more determined than ever to re-establish their identity as a people in their ancient homeland.

Less than one year prior to their move from Italy, my father along with his best friend Zvi and their battalion had finished sweeping up the boot of Italy and cleansing it of German troops.  They had been camped at their new base in Trieste, a northern port town near the border of Italy and Yugoslavia.  The Jewish boys, part of that Palestinian unit of the British Army, had been befriended by a small group of local Jewish young adults.  It was a moment of destiny for those two boys - my father and his friend Zvi - in many ways.

At an evening gathering at a local club, Zvi had met Vita, a beautiful Italian-born Jewish girl whose family had escaped the pogroms of Russia two decades earlier.  It didn't take long for him to fall deeply in love with this brash and fiesty 22 year old.  Three months later they were married in a civil ceremony attended by his fellow soldiers and many of the small local Jewish community that they had befriended.  Of course, my mother, Vita's sister - her bride's mate - attended the wedding with her then fiancé.  Sadly for her fiancé, who wasn't much of a dancer, Zvi's best friend was also part of the group reveling in the celebration.

My father and mother met on the dance floor that night and for three hours danced until the blisters on their feet cried out for mercy.  The rest, as they say, is history.  The next day, my mother returned the engagement ring to her poor former fiancé, and began spending every moment she was able to with my father.  They planned on marrying some time soon.  Unfortunately, the joy of that moment of providence was short-lived.

It had been seven years since my father had escaped Czechoslovakia during the German occupation of
The Sudetenland after his mother put him along with a dozen other Jewish 14 and 15 year old boys on a train to Denmark.  That event foretold an ominous future for the Jews of Eastern Europe.  Soon thereafter, although they desperately tried, it was impossible for the Jewish boys to return to Prague and my father and his group made the fateful decision to attempt the journey to the Palestinian territory where thousands of other Jews were attempting to go.  After multiple harrowing experiences during their three month journey, they arrived in the middle east, soon after joined the British Army and fought for nearly six years against Rommel in Northern Africa before being moved to the European front.

So, after seven years, Czechoslovakia was finally liberated from German control and my father was granted a weekend pass from his unit in Trieste to return to Prague to find his family.   My mother, with memories of her father being arrested by the SS and having found out not long before that he died on a train to one of the German death camps, had a very foreboding sense about this trip, but could not - would not - let my father know about her feelings.  He had to go.  As my father left in his British Army Jeep, my mother suddenly felt very alone.  The memories of her own six years of terror were running through her mind - hiding from the SS with her mother and Vita in rat infested attics, sleeping in barns, narrowly escaping capture time and time again.

Three days later there was a knock on my mother's door.  She opened it to find my father, exhausted from no sleep, tears streaming down his face.  They fell into each others arms, both crying uncontrollably - he didn't have to say a word.  She knew.

For the next several hours they locked themselves in the bathroom and sat on the cold tile floor crying together, my father too embarrassed to allow anyone else to see him in this state.  He told her the story, from arriving in Prague, finding no one he knew in all the old houses in the Jewish neighborhoods he grew up in and ultimately, going to the city hall and researching the records of his family.  You see, the Germans kept meticulous records.

And there, his worst nightmares were revealed.  His mother, father, two sisters...his brother-in-law and niece...his aunts, uncles, cousins, grandparents...all gone...taken to Auschwitz-Birkenau...gassed, burnt...dead.  He alone was left.  My father was never the same after that.  Although, he and my mother did eventually marry, moved to Bat Galim, and began to put the pieces of life back together.

In partnership with my uncle, my father was part of the underground - helping to obtain and hide weapons for the Haganah and Palmach in their struggle for independence from the British and against Arab terrorism.  They helped to establish the fledging State of Israel during its war of Independence and thereafter.  My brother was born in 1948 and soon after, my cousin Ruthi was born.   The two families living together at times to make ends meet, raising their children together...surviving with memories...and with a hope that never again will the Jewish people be defenseless against evil and tyranny.

My parents eventually moved to the United States to be with my grandmother who had moved to the US from Italy after the war.  I was born not long after.  My aunt Vita, uncle Zvi, and my other aunt and uncle - Olga and Jackie, who had moved to the region before World War II had ended - remained in Israel and each raised two beautiful children, several grandchildren and many great grandchildren.  They went on to endure more bloodshed, wars, terrorism, and grief.  My oldest cousin was killed by a mine around the time of the Six Day War.

My mother is the sole surviver of her family now, her mother, sisters, brother - who all survived the holocaust - all since have passed on to their eternal home.  My father has passed also, having lived with a grief that no one should ever have to bare...a survivor's guilt that a boy emotionally entrenched at the age of 15 could never begin to understand.  He was a man who quietly, constantly ruminated over the question...if I was only there, could I have saved my family...could I have protected them?  His best friend, my uncle Zvi, has also passed on, leaving a legacy of strength that will never be forgotten.

Today, Israel commemorates a national holiday - if one can call it that.  It is Yom HaShoah (literally, The Day of The Holocaust) - the date on the calendar that we remember the Six Million men, women and children whose lives were prematurely taken by evil in human form.  It is a day filled with grief - to most it is a collection of stories, of distant memories one, two and three generations removed from the event.  Nevertheless, it is faithfully commemorated and will be for as long as Israel exists throughout generations to come.

But, it is also a day filled with thanksgiving and hope.  We give thanks for and honor men like uncle Zvi and my father, women like Vita and my mother, who didn't just survive the holocaust, but fought through and somehow transcended the grief and the living memories...to build a nation from dirt and rock into what is now "a land filled with milk and honey."  We have hope that the children of the survivors, the grandchildren and great grandchildren can one day live in peace, focused only on how they can help the world become a better place and less on surviving the next onslaught of anti-semitic treachery.

Today, Holocaust Remembrance Day, reminds us that our Creator, the G-d of this universe, is not a puppet master.  He has given us out of His great love for us, the free will to choose...we have the capability as a race and as individuals to do enormous evil.  We also have the capacity to do tremendous good.  The Torah says in the book of Deuteronomy, "I call heaven and earth to witness today that before you is life and death, the blessing and the curse.  Therefore, choose life, so that you will live, you and your descendants, loving Adonai your G-d, clinging to Him..."  WE have been given the ability to choose between good and evil, between life and death, between becoming a blessing or a curse to others, to be beneficent or malevolent.

Yom HaShoah also reminds us that even if others have chosen evil over good, the curse over the blessing, death over life, we still have the capacity to survive even the most vile onslaught to our humanness and to rebuild in hopes of a better day.  Today, we traditionally say, "Never again...never forget!"  But, we also say, "The nation of Israel lives" - Am Yisrael Chai!

Friday, April 5, 2013

Happy 65th Birthday, Israel!


Happy 65th Birthday, Israel!

An Essay By  


For many nations, a 65th birthday may not generate much excitement. But if the country happens to be Israel, which celebrates its birthday this year on April 15-16, it's another story.

Israel has the dubious distinction of being the only UN member state whose right to exist is regularly challenged, whose elimination from the world map is the aim of at least one other UN member state (Iran), and whose population centers are deemed fair game by Hamas-controlled Gaza and Hezbollah-dominated Lebanon.
None of the countries that are serial human-rights violators--not Iran, North Korea, Belarus, Zimbabwe, Sudan, or any of the others--gets anything near the relentless, obsessive, guilty-till-proven-innocent scrutiny that democratic Israel receives from UN bodies, with their built-in, anti-Israel majorities, in New York and Geneva.
Indeed, Israel is the only nation in the world which has a permanent, separate agenda item at the UN Human Rights Council. All other countries in the world are lumped together under another agenda item.
No other country is the target of such non-stop, well-funded, and highly-organized campaigns to discredit, delegitimize, and demonize a sovereign state.
No other country faces systematic attempts to launch boycotts, divestment campaigns, and sanctions against it, not to mention flotillas and flytillas. All the while those behind the efforts, claiming to speak in the lofty name of human rights, studiously ignore places like Syria, where more than 70,000 have been killed in the past two years alone and numberless more wounded, homeless, exiled, and detained. Why this lack of interest in Syria? Presumably because no Israeli connection can be claimed.
No other country has its right to self-defense challenged as Israel does, even though it acts no differently than any other nation would if confronted by periodic terrorist assaults and deadly missile and rocket attacks.
And no other country is as microscopically examined in the media, from the BBC to the Financial Times, from CNN International to the wire services, leading to such typical whoppers as the New York Timesheadline on April 4th - "Tensions Rise As Israel and Gaza Swap Strikes." Rockets were fired from Gaza at Israel, Israel responded to defend its citizens, and to the newspaper of record, it's an antiseptically 50-50 equation between the attacker and the attacked.
I have enormous admiration for Israel - for its resolve, resilience, courage, and ingenuity.
What it has achieved in the past 65 years is breathtaking: the rebirth of a state with a rock-solid democratic foundation; the ingathering of millions of refugees and immigrants from just about every corner of the world; the creation of a world-class economy; the building of a first-rate army; and a determination to overcome one seemingly insurmountable obstacle after another.
Other nations might have succumbed, after 65 years of uninterrupted hostility, to enemies trying everything under the sun to destroy them, and short of that, to demoralize and isolate them. But Israel has not flinched. It refuses to cave. It keeps confounding its foes.
Its commitment to a two-state accord with the Palestinians, polls repeatedly reveal, remains unshakeable, even as many Israelis can't help but wonder if the Palestinians, given one chance after another for sovereignty, truly share Israel's aim of Jewish and Palestinian states living side by side in peace and harmony.
Moreover, in global surveys Israel comes out among the "happiest" countries in the world; Tel Aviv ranks as one of the top "go-to" destinations for young people; and Israelis' life expectancy exceeds that of Americans'.
How can it be, Israel's adversaries ask, that these "sons of monkeys and pigs," as radical Muslim preachers openly refer to the Jews (and as Egyptian President Mohamed Morsi declared three years ago, while a Muslim Brotherhood leader), manage to stand tall, strong, and, yes, optimistic? How can it be that this nation of just eight million, grown from only 650,000 at its birth in 1948, repeatedly defeats far more populous Arab foes that have arrayed themselves against it? How can it be that these Jews, seemingly led to slaughter like sheep by the Third Reich, suddenly learned how to defend themselves and vanquish larger Arab armies, within three years of V-E Day? And how can it be that Israel, with no natural resources to speak of until recent natural gas findings, could achieve a first-world economy, catapulting it into the OECD; double-digit winners of Nobel Prizes; top-three ranking in new NASDAQ listings; and global recognition as a leader in innovation and entrepreneurship?
Too often, Israel's adversaries have come up with misguided if self-satisfying answers, usually elaborate conspiracy theories inspired by anti-Semitic tropes.
In reality, though, the answer is much simpler. It derives from an age-old connection among a land, a faith, and a people. Many have tried to sever the link. All have failed.
Consider the words of Ezekiel, expressed some 2,700 years ago:
Thus says the Lord God: Behold, I will take the people of Israel from the nations among which they have gone, and will gather them from all sides, and bring them to their own land; and I will make them one nation in the land, upon the mountains of Israel... And the desolate land shall be tilled... And they shall say, This land that was desolate is become like the Garden of Eden.
Or, to fast forward from the ancient prophet Ezekiel to the prophetic Winston Churchill:
The coming into being of a Jewish State in Palestine is an event in world history to be viewed in the perspective not of a generation or a century, but in the perspective of a thousand, two thousand or even three thousand years.
Churchill added that the state's establishment was "one of the most hopeful and encouraging adventures of the 20th century."
Indeed, so it continues to be in the 21st century.
To be sure, Israel, like all democratic societies, is a permanent work in progress. Much remains to be done.
From grappling with a less-than-ideal electoral system to dealing with religious zealots who invoke a "higher authority" than the state, from addressing a yawning gap between rich and poor to balancing the Jewish and democratic nature of the country, from the decades-long pursuit of peace with its neighbors to the defense of the country in an ever more turbulent region, Israel has no shortage of challenges.
But, above all, Israel is a wondrous "adventure." I feel privileged daily to see the fulfillment of the prayers of generations longing for a return to Zion from forced exile.
Witnessing Soviet Jews arriving at Ben-Gurion Airport even as Saddam Hussein's Scud missiles came raining down, while Israel did not miss a beat in welcoming the newcomers, reveals the country's character.
So, too, being in Rambam Hospital in Haifa during Hezbollah missile attacks. One minute, a siren would sound and everyone would calmly go, or be moved, to the bomb shelters. The next minute, after the all-clear signal, the scientists would return to their labs to continue cutting-edge research in cancer, diabetes, and stem-cell therapy.
Or visiting Barzilai Hospital in Ashkelon, where victims of Hamas strikes against Israel were taken for medical care, and seeing Palestinian patients from Gaza in rooms adjoining the Jewish wounded.
Or getting to know Save a Child's Heart, an Israeli program that provides life-saving pediatric heart surgery. Many of the children come from Arab countries that deny Israel's very existence.
Or seeing the scrawling on a Tel Aviv wall shortly after 21 young Israelis were killed at a discotheque -- "They won't stop us from dancing."
Or watching an Israeli Arab Supreme Court justice -- who, incidentally, refuses to sing Israel's national anthem -- sit on a panel that upheld the conviction of an Israeli ex-president on charges of rape.
Or imagining the role Israel could one day play in the region in helping advance food security, water security, energy security, environmental security, public health security, and knowledge security, all of which will be towering issues in the 21st century.
No, this Israel may not now feature prominently in the media, I'm sorry to say, but it is the Israel that pulsates daily with a love of life, of freedom, and of the land.
Happy 65th Birthday, Israel!
*This essay is an adaptation of an earlier version written by the author.
headshot.jpgDavid Harris has been Executive Director of the American Jewish Committee (AJC) since 1990. AJC has been described by the New York Times as “the dean of American Jewish organizations.” Harris has been honored by the governments of Bulgaria, France, Germany, Italy, Latvia, Poland, Spain and Ukraine for his work on transatlantic relations, human rights, historical memory and intergroup understanding. He was educated at the University of Pennsylvania and London School of Economics. He was a Junior Associate at Oxford University’s St. Antony’s College (1977-78), a Visiting Scholar at the Johns Hopkins University School of Advanced International Studies (2000-02), and a Senior Associate at St. Antony’s College (2009-11). Since 2001, he has broadcast a weekly commentary on the CBS Radio network, and since 2007, he has had a blog on international affairs at theJerusalem Post.